« Passing Over | Main | 1 For 6 »

Public Privacy

Cell phones have spread across the country like a disease or a meme or zombies. There's no avoiding them, especially in the city. But the city holds other dangers and you can't always be sure that cell phones are the answer to all of the little idiosyncracies of city life. They have these things now, these tiny little things that you stick in your ear. They're like the bugs out of Dune or Star Trek II, only they connect to your cellphone and let you use it without using your hands. Oh, and they're not alive. But they are hard to see when they're up against dark clothing, and almost everyone in the city wears dark clothing. It may well be a law. So what happens is you get people walking down the street and having a conversation with thin air. They may, they just may, be talking on their cell phone. But this is the city, so it may just as easily be a dangerous lunatic walking right next to you instead.

Today on the train home I was treated to another fun cell phone experience. There was a woman sitting next to me, about my age, not entirely un-cute if you're into the blonde, salon-tanned, Lerner-wearing look, which I am decidedly not. But I don't think my saying she was "next to me" does justice to exactly how close we were. There were individual molecules gasping for breath between our hips. Another man say on her opposite side. I could feel tectonic shifts when they brushed against each other. This was a crowded train. And this woman had the projection of an opera singer. Her voice really rang out.

For half an hour I heard the woman talk. I heard her talk about her new job (she's an assistant marketing director for Elle). I heard her talk about the new apartment she and her fiancee, Jeremy, are hoping to get (on the upper east side with a wonderful view and a lovely alcove in the dining room, all for only $2,500 a month). I heard her talk about how supportive her mother has been, unlike her father that prick. I heard her say, and this is a direct quote now, "I've been so busy I haven't had time to shave my pussy in two weeks, so Jeremy's just going to have to suck it up."

Go and read that last line again. I don't want to repeat it.

I heard her say this and I said "lady, please! I did not need to hear that."

And the woman looked at me, looked at me as if I'd burst into her living room or her office, and said "excuse me, I'm trying to have a conversation here."

The conductor announced my stop a second later, so I was spared whatever else she had to say, but the experience left me feeling... funny. Are we becoming, are cell phones making us, a society where privacy is assumed in public? A society where it's acceptable to say whatever you want and people will ignore it to leave you with your dignity? Pre-modern Japan, with its tightly-packed, paper-walled houses had a very similar thing going on, where it was almost impossible not to overhear conversations and so the Japanese created an elaborate system of metaphor to indirectly talk about whatever they wanted and not embarass each other. But we don't have that. Strange days we live in...

Comments (3)

Erik (the roommate):

I had a very similar experience in a doctor's office once, and it's just going to get more common as personal communications tech continues to advance and spread. The main problem is that there are a great many people who are "closet assholes," meaning that in a public setting, they're fundamentally nice people, but when you have to hear their private concerns, they become, well, jackasses. Not giving a damn about what other people have to listen to is just one symptom of Closet Asshole Syndrome (CLASS).

Isaac Asimov's novel Caves of Steel (Doubleday, 1954) dealt with the issue of privacy in public places in a very mature fashion for the age. In the far flung future of domed cities and sprawling arcologies, privacy is a state of mind. You shower and dress in semi-public rest rooms with 10 micron aluminum walls. The sounds of the apartments near you are crystal clear in your own bedroom, and nothing is left to the imagination. Yet still, everyone goes about their business as if they were completely isolated from each other, and the gentle hum of humanity becomes a comforting white noise that you both ignore and depend upon for comfort.

This has 2 effects:

1. Everyone becomes agoraphobic.

2. Being observant works against you.

Regardless of what you think of Asimov and the Robot series, it's an excellent book and remarkably relevant to moderm life.

Jon (from the cornfields):

First off... I had to read it three times to make sure I read it right. Secondly, I like Erik's CLASS disease. I think someone should send it to the American Psyciatric Association and see if it can't make it on the books somewhere.

Fortunately, I don't like in "the city" and so much better off my life is for it. Yes, there are an alarming number of cellphones here, but people don't feel the need to use them all the time and most people are still offended when people are using them in line at the grocery store.

We may live simple, but we still have values.

On the opposite side of that spectrum, however, I've had sex outdoors, in full daylight where there were pedestrians no more than ten feet away from me, and didn't miss a beat. Not something I think I'd do anymore in my old age, but I can't say I haven't done my part of bringing private lives into the public.

Jason:

I'm going to gloss over actually thinking about your statement, Jon, and simply say that in theory, despite your nearness to other people, you weren't screaming/grunting/whatever for all to hear and you weren't in the middle of an open field where people saw you. I'm going to assume that you were at least hidden somewhere, in a bush or something.

And if you weren't, I don't want to know.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on April 7, 2004 10:33 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Passing Over.

The next post in this blog is 1 For 6.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.31