(or: So When Is R. Talsorian Re-Releasing Castle Falkenstein?)
Stardust opened yesterday. You've probably seen the commercials; they feature Michelle Pfieffer and Robert deNiro, even though neither one of them actually stars in the movie. The movie's based on the (profoundly awesome) "fairy-tale for adults" novel written by Neil Gaiman, and you all know I'm a big fan of Mr. Neil Gaiman. Also, the director said he was going for a "Princess Bride meets Pirates of the Caribbean" vibe in making the thing.
I had some high expectations for this movie, going in, is what I'm trying to say.
Let me say, right up front, that my expectations were not disappointed in the end. I really loved the movie.
Now, that said, I think the first act was a little weak - fairly rushed and not wonderfully written; heavy-handed at times without needing or even meaning to be. It was enjoyable enough, but I spent those first 20 minutes or so with a sinking feeling in my gut, going "is this it? It's nice, but is this as good as it's going to get?"
About 20-30 minutes in, starting from the sequence at the inn, everything started to pick up. After that, there was enough danger to keep the rushed parts feeling right, and enough relaxation to let the writers (and actors) take their time.
Now, as is true with almost any book-made-movie there were changes in plot made in the transition. Most of them, I felt, only enhanced the story for film. Getting rid of the concept of the Market as a thing Wall-folk and other-folk both went to, for example, was a good thing; it would've taken too much out of the film to handle that way. Extending the sequence in the air to more than a quick narration was a great idea, and worked fab-ulously (heh, heh), though I'm not sure I like the captain's name change.
On the other hand, there were a few changes that I found... irksome. Of course, they were almost all in the first act, so I probably just wish they hadn't changed so that act hadn't felt so rushed. I preferred the book's way of Tristan getting over the Wall, where his father talks to the guard and they agree to let him cross. I miss the sequence with the serewood, and think it could've been rewritten to include Yvainne and add some early danger and tension.
I could've definitely done without the coronation at the end; Tristan and Yvainne purposefully leaving to go on more adventures together is just more fun. But, then, that would've worked a little better if Una came across as more manipulative, as she did in the book, which was cool.
That, then, is Stardust in a nutshell. Very, very, very worth seeing. You should go and see it, if you haven't already. Right now. I, myself, am tempted to go and see it again today, actually. Even if I don't, I know that I'll buy on DVD and watching QUITE a lot of.